BPM Asks: What are rising paramedical costs doing to plan design?

Lockton wants the dollars pooled, Normandin Beaudry wants mental health walled off from the pool

BPM Asks: What are rising paramedical costs doing to plan design?

Mental-health practitioner claims across Canadian group benefits plans have climbed nearly 3.5 times since 2019, and more than tripled among employees under 30. Sun Life attributed almost all of that growth to a rise in the share of members claiming rather than heavier use per member, in its Designed for Health report released in October.

Benefits and Pensions Monitor put the same five questions on paramedical maximums to two benefits consultants.

Mental-health support paid out by Canadian insurers reached nearly $1.1bn in 2025, up 160 percent over five years, according to the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association.

Budget 2026 proposed adding qualifying massage therapists to the list of practitioners whose services are exempt from GST/HST for supplies made after November 5, 2026, a measure that is not yet law.

What paramedical spend is doing to plan costs

“Across our clients, paramedical is still usually a much smaller share of health costs than prescription drugs, but it’s one of the fastest growing, and mental health is leading that growth,” said Arslan Arshad, senior principal, health and benefits at Normandin Beaudry, in an email to Benefits and Pensions Monitor.

Julie Duchesne, people solutions leader at Lockton Canada, put it higher up the cost curve. “Over the past few years, the category has become a significant driver of overall plan cost growth, propelled primarily by mental health practitioners,” she said in an email to Benefits and Pensions Monitor.

Where sponsors have raised their mental-health maximums, she said, they “now often reach near $2,700 annually.”

Paramedical claims rose 16 percent in 2024 and nine percent in 2025, Arshad said, citing the insurance association, with mental-health benefits up roughly 20 percent last year. Drug plans carry formularies, prior authorization, and generic substitution, he said, while paramedical coverage mostly carries a dollar maximum.

Professional fees for psychologists and licensed psychotherapists “adjust annually based on market demand and regional association guidelines, often sitting between $220 and $260 per hour,” according to Duchesne, while maximums are reviewed “typically only during a comprehensive plan redesign or at a challenging renewal every three to five years.”

Improving paramedical coverage without more money

The two consultants disagree on where the dollars should sit.

Duchesne would pool them. Traditional plans often give each allied health practitioner its own small maximum, “such as $500 each for acupuncture, osteopathy, podiatry, and naturopathy,” she said, and only a small fraction of the workforce ever uses them while mental health coverage is exhausted early in the year.

“Gives members meaningful purchasing power where they actually need it, without expanding the employer’s total liability”

Julie Duchesne, Lockton Canada

Combining those categories into a shared pool, or shifting funds into a Healthcare Spending Account, “gives members meaningful purchasing power where they actually need it, without expanding the employer’s total liability,” Duchesne said.

Arshad would separate them. “Widen first and protect mental health separately,” he said. In a shared pool, “mental-health care competes with every other paramedical service for the same dollars,” and 38 percent of sponsors now cover counselling inside a combined paramedical maximum, up from 25 percent a year earlier, Arshad said.

“Widen first and protect mental health separately”

Arslan Arshad, Normandin Beaudry

Raising a combined maximum “mostly funds the heaviest existing users,” he said.

What a rising claim denial rate signals

“When more than half of members report a denied claim, the issue is usually coverage exhaustion rather than ineligible submissions,” Duchesne said.

A standard course of psychotherapy for depression or anxiety runs 12 to 15 sessions, she said, and under an older $1,500 maximum an employee exhausts coverage after roughly six.

“That suggests many of those denials come from practitioner eligibility or documentation, not from exhausted limits”

Arslan Arshad, Normandin Beaudry

Arshad reads the same figure the other way. “I wouldn’t read too much into the industry figures,” he said, pointing to 52 percent of members reporting a denied claim against 44 percent in 2019.

On the paramedical side, 15 percent of members have had a mental-health claim denied while nine percent reached their mental-health maximum, Arshad said. “That suggests many of those denials come from practitioner eligibility or documentation, not from exhausted limits.”

The number that counts, he said, “is each sponsor’s own denial rate, broken down by cause.”

Redesigning paramedical coverage from scratch

“I would tell sponsors to drop the default $300-to-$500 benchmark and design around what their workforce actually values,” Duchesne said. For care that affects disability outcomes, she would fund a maximum number of visits rather than “an arbitrary dollar cap that cuts treatment off halfway.”

Arshad would begin with the conditions. “Start from health and wellbeing objectives and establish the conditions you want to treat, not the list of practitioners,” he said.

Most plans share costs with employees, he added, so richer coverage is not free for them either and “everyone can end up paying more, including those who rarely use the benefit.”

The goal, Arshad said, “is to make sure the dollars buy impactful coverage.”